A faint wisp of smoke against a clear early August sky was the initial harbinger of a significant wildfire that ignited in New Mexico’s Sangre de Cristo Mountains. Sparked by a lightning strike near the historic village of Cundiyó, the blaze rapidly consumed the drought-parched canyons surrounding the Río Frijoles. This vital waterway, along with the nearby Río en Medio, originates in the Sangre de Cristo range and flows into Santa Cruz Lake. From this reservoir, their waters are channeled into the Santa Cruz River, which is further augmented by the Río Quemado.
These waterways are the lifeblood of several centuries-old agricultural communities, their sustenance delivered through an intricate network of approximately 30 hand-dug irrigation channels, known as acequias. These ancient systems, collectively owned and managed by around 3,000 parciantes, or community members, predate the Santa Cruz Lake dam by many generations. Recognized as political subdivisions of New Mexico, the acequias are governed by dedicated commissions and individual mayordomos, who meticulously oversee the distribution and upkeep of this precious resource.
However, with more than half of the Río Frijoles watershed directly in the fire’s path, the very health of the watershed and the future of the region’s irrigation practices faced an immediate and severe threat. Ron Gallegos, chair of the Santa Cruz Irrigation District, which manages water for downstream irrigators, described the anxious wait for news, fearing the potential depletion of the lake. "Once it started, I was just waiting for a call, a text, a message from somebody to see if they could pump water from the lake," Gallegos recounted, his concern palpable. "And sure enough, they did."
Within days, U.S. Forest Service aircraft were actively engaged, scooping vast quantities of water from Santa Cruz Lake to combat the flames and deploying fire retardant slurry to slow the inferno’s relentless advance. Gallegos’s Irrigation District entered into an agreement with the Forest Service, receiving a nominal payment of one cent per gallon of water extracted from the lake. While the compensation amounted to approximately $8,500 for roughly 850,000 gallons – a comparatively small volume in the grand scheme of firefighting – the imperative to protect the watershed, which sustains the livelihoods of some 3,000 people, made the effort feel profoundly worthwhile.
As of early October, nearly two months after the Frijoles Fire first ignited, containment efforts had reached about 90%. An initial assessment indicated that the majority of the fire had burned at a low intensity, potentially mitigating the most severe post-fire ecological impacts. Nevertheless, lingering concerns about potential flooding leading to increased sediment and turbidity in the lake persist, raising anxieties among local communities regarding the quality of their essential water supply, especially in light of the fire retardant chemicals used.

Even before the Frijoles Fire cast its shadow, the region had been grappling with the increasing volatility of its climate. Recent years have witnessed rapid and extreme weather shifts, oscillating between prolonged drought and intense, torrential rainfall, making irrigation a precarious undertaking. This year, a meager snowpack and persistently high temperatures severely curtailed natural runoff, leading to critically low water levels. "It could be the worst on record," stated Steve Finch, a hydrogeologist and geochemist with an Albuquerque-based firm, highlighting the dire situation. A nearby U.S. Geological Survey gauge registered a mere 4 cubic feet per second throughout the summer, a stark contrast to the typical 20 to 30 cubic feet per second expected during this period.
These diminished and warmer water levels contributed to an earlier-than-usual algae bloom, transforming the lake into a murky green expanse and imbuing it with a strong, unpleasant odor. Joel Esquibel, who operates and maintains the Santa Cruz Dam, a role inherited from his father, meticulously monitors the lake’s water levels. He described his growing apprehension as the fire raged, noting that the water level had only been lower during a dredging operation in the late 1980s. Fortunately, by the end of September, a moisture plume associated with Hurricane Polo brought a much-needed 15-foot rise in the lake’s level.
However, the threat of excessive water also carries its own set of risks. In 2025, a historic flood event devastated critical acequia infrastructure, halting irrigation for extended periods as small communities undertook the arduous task of rebuilding headgates and clearing months’ worth of debris and silt – a process that demanded significant time and hundreds of thousands of dollars. This September’s unusually heavy rains, while welcome in replenishing some water reserves, also carried fire debris and silt from the Frijoles Fire into Santa Cruz Lake. Finch expressed concern that this influx will inevitably reduce the reservoir’s storage capacity. He estimates that over the past century, Santa Cruz Lake has already accumulated approximately 1,000 acre-feet of silt, representing a quarter of its original capacity. The precise volume of silt deposited by the recent post-fire rains remains to be determined, but Finch acknowledged that future dredging will be necessary to restore its storage capabilities.
The concerns surrounding the Frijoles Fire extend beyond immediate water availability and quality. On August 4th, the very day the fire began, New Mexico Representative Teresa Leger Fernández, a Democrat, formally requested that the Government Accountability Office, a federal watchdog agency, investigate the prevalence and potential environmental effects of toxic metals present in fire retardants used by the Forest Service and the Department of the Interior. The letter, co-signed by eight other members of Congress, emphasized the "essential, lifesaving support" provided by aerial firefighting operations while also acknowledging that "recent reports have raised questions about the safety of fire retardants commonly used by aerial firefighters."
A spokesperson for the Forest Service, Claudia Brookshire, stated via email that "All fire retardants used by the Forest Service fall into the Environmental Protection Agency’s ‘practically non-toxic’ category for mammals, including humans, and aquatic species." She further clarified that the Forest Service strictly "prohibits retardant drops within waterways and within mapped avoidance areas for cultural resources, or threatened, endangered, proposed, candidate or sensitive species." While the primary components of fire retardants are two forms of phosphate, widely utilized in fertilizers, independent investigations in California, following the Palisades, Eaton, and Franklin fires, detected the presence of arsenic, cadmium, chromium, and lead in collected samples.
Further compounding these concerns, independent analyses conducted three years after the devastating Hermit’s Peak/Calf Canyon Fire, which scorched over 340,000 acres of northern New Mexico forest lands, revealed the presence of heavy metals in private well water. A report in 2026 attributed these findings to a combination of naturally occurring ores and the remnants of burnt structures and fire suppressants. The Forest Service reported that approximately 453,000 gallons of retardant were deployed on the Frijoles Fire, representing more than a quarter of the 1,600,000 gallons used on the much larger Hermit’s Peak/Calf Canyon Fire. The Frijoles Fire, at 16,000 acres, is considerably smaller, encompassing less than 5% of the area burned by the Hermit’s Peak blaze.

When questioned at a public meeting in early September in the nearby village of Truchas about the presence of heavy metals in the fire retardant used on the Frijoles Fire, Lawrence Lujan, a deputy district ranger for the Santa Fe National Forest, deferred inquiries to the manufacturer. Zak Bollenbacher, president of the Americas Retardants business at Perimeter Solutions, the retardant’s manufacturer, stated in an email that "No heavy metals are added to any PHOS-CHEK fire retardant formulations; any trace amounts of heavy metals present are naturally occurring within the raw materials used to formulate the solution." He added that the phosphate used in the Frijoles Fire retardant undergoes rigorous processing to reduce "heavy metal levels below fertilizer grade."
Phos-Chek, a brand of firefighting foam developed by Monsanto in the late 1960s, is applied to curb wildfire progression. While most of its ingredients are publicly disclosed in material safety data sheets, a small percentage remains proprietary as trade secrets. This opacity prompted a research team from the University of Southern California to investigate the presence of heavy metals in retardants, analyzing data from fires between 2009 and 2021. Their 2024 study examined 14 types of retardants, including three from the Phos-Chek line, now under Perimeter Solutions’ ownership. The research revealed that one product, Phos-Chek LC95W, utilized for ground applications and phased out by the Forest Service in 2024, contained heavy metal levels significantly exceeding the EPA’s drinking water standards. The agency confirmed the use of a formulation within the same Phos-Chek product line on the Hermit’s Peak/Calf Canyon blaze, which contained similar ingredients but featured a red coloring for aerial application.
Phos-Chek MVP-Fx, another retardant employed on the Hermit’s Peak fire and, according to Bollenbacher, instrumental in "help[ing] contain the Frijoles Fire," was also used on recent major fires in California. Subsequent analysis by the USC team identified toxic heavy metals in this formulation. Lead researcher Daniel McCurry noted that the USC team did not analyze the second retardant used on the Frijoles Fire, Phos-Chek 259-Fx, due to a lack of access to manufacturer samples.
On the ground, the parciantes of the acequias anxiously await the future, observing that the entire lake has taken on a dark, ash-like hue. Concerns regarding water quality remain paramount. Finch indicated that no further water releases are scheduled for the remainder of the year, allowing any accumulated debris and silt to settle over the winter months. This natural settling process suggests that the contaminants are unlikely to be distributed into the acequias this year, offering a temporary reprieve for the communities reliant on these ancient water systems.

