In a move reverberating across Native American communities and environmental advocacy groups, a subsidiary of Energy Fuels, a prominent mining company, revived its plans in 2024 to open the Roca Honda Uranium Mine in New Mexico. This proposed mine sits precariously close to Mount Taylor, a site of profound cultural and spiritual significance to at least 30 Native nations, including the Navajo Nation, Acoma Pueblo, Laguna Pueblo, Zuni Pueblo, and Hopi Tribe. The company had previously secured expedited permitting under the Trump administration, and in a critical development, the U.S. Forest Service announced in mid-September that it would commence its mandated analysis of the mine’s potential environmental impacts under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). This NEPA process, a cornerstone of U.S. environmental law, is designed to ensure that federal agencies consider the environmental consequences of proposed actions and provide opportunities for public and tribal input. Integral to this process is tribal consultation, a legal and moral imperative crucial for upholding sovereign tribal nations’ inherent rights to protect their ancestral lands, cultural landscapes, precious wildlife habitats, and vital water resources. However, the efficacy of such consultation and, indeed, the very framework of environmental protection, now faces an existential challenge from proposed legislative changes.

A sweeping legislative initiative, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a permitting reform bill introduced by a bipartisan group of Western senators, including New Mexico’s Democratic Senator Martin Heinrich and Utah’s Republican Senator Mike Lee, threatens to dramatically alter the landscape of environmental review and tribal consultation. The Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources was slated to vote on this contentious bill shortly after Congress’s return on November 9, with significant implications for how infrastructure and resource extraction projects are approved across federal lands.

This ambitious legislation proposes far-reaching changes, extending its reach well beyond NEPA to affect other foundational environmental statutes such as the Endangered Species Act (ESA), the Clean Water Act (CWA), and critically, the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). The stated aim of this permitting reform is to accelerate the development of industrial projects, encompassing everything from new mines, wind turbines, and vast solar arrays to data centers and pipelines, particularly on federal lands. Proponents argue that streamlining these processes is essential for bolstering the nation’s energy independence, fostering economic growth, and facilitating the transition to a cleaner energy future. Yet, this push for speed has ignited fierce opposition from Native leaders and organizations, who contend that such accelerated development comes at an unacceptable cost to tribal sovereignty and environmental integrity. A central grievance among tribal nations is the profound lack of consultation they received prior to the bill’s introduction, an oversight they view as a direct violation of their sovereign status and a betrayal of federal trust responsibilities.

Sacred sites like Mount Taylor in New Mexico and the broader Chaco landscape, spanning parts of Colorado, Arizona, and Utah, represent just a fraction of the myriad places that stand to be impacted by this legislation. These areas, often lying outside reservation boundaries, are protected primarily through federal law, which provides tribal nations a voice when projects like mines, pipelines, or transmission lines threaten their cultural resources, sacred sites, and communities. As Acoma Pueblo Governor Charles Riley powerfully articulated at a national conference of tribal leaders in October, "Many of these places are outside our reservations. Federal law is how we have a voice when a mine, a pipeline or a transmission line is proposed that impacts our cultural resources, our sacred sites and our communities directly. This bill would take away most of that." His words underscore the profound vulnerability many tribal communities would face if these legal protections are eroded.

Should the proposed legislation pass in its current form, federal agencies could gain the discretionary power to forgo consultation with tribal nations regarding cultural sites at risk of damage from projects such as the Roca Honda Mine. While the Acoma Pueblo, notably, does not oppose the Roca Honda project due to a specific settlement with the company that resulted in significant concessions and project modifications, the Navajo Nation and Isleta Pueblo remain staunchly opposed, highlighting the complex and varied perspectives within Indian Country. Beyond consultation, the bill proposes shortening timelines for reviewing complex environmental and cultural impact documents and would narrow the scope of federal agency consideration to only impacts on federal land, even if a project, like the Roca Honda Mine, extends across state and private lands. This fragmentation of review would inevitably lead to incomplete assessments and potentially devastating consequences for interconnected ecosystems and cultural landscapes. In essence, the legislation threatens to further distance tribal nations from federal decision-making processes concerning their ancestral lands, severely limiting their legal options should a proposed project infringe upon their rights or threaten their heritage.

New bill slashes tribes’ role in projects that impact ancestral sites, water and wildlife

The gravity of the situation was succinctly captured by Mark Macarro (Pechanga), president of the National Congress of American Indians (NCAI), who declared at his organization’s conference, "This is one of those extreme, existential threats that’s in front of us right now." He urged senators to make dramatic changes to the bill before the November vote, unequivocally stating that without such amendments, "this bill needs to be killed." This stark warning reflects a deep-seated concern that the proposed reforms represent a fundamental assault on tribal self-determination and the hard-won gains in environmental justice.

Tribal leaders and organizations are particularly alarmed by proposed alterations to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). Currently, Section 106 mandates federal agencies to consult with tribes if a project has the potential to impact a cultural site. The proposed changes are expansive and deeply problematic: tribal consultation would become optional, the very scope of what constitutes an impact requiring consultation would be significantly narrowed, and cultural sites would not need to be considered at all if they were not formally identified before a review process commenced. This last point is especially troubling, as many sacred sites are not publicly documented to protect them from desecration or looting, relying instead on tribal knowledge and the current consultation process for identification.

Ira Matt (Séliš), executive director for Indigenous Diplomacy and Federal Relations for the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers (NATHPO), unequivocally labeled the proposed changes as "a direct assault on tribal sovereignty." NATHPO, alongside the NCAI and other indigenous advocacy groups, has called for the complete removal of the NHPA section from the bill. Matt elaborated that the legislation would severely restrict how tribes define and protect their cultural heritage, fundamentally undermining their inherent rights to participate in decisions that directly affect their histories and futures. He further criticized the bill for placing "wholly unqualified federal agencies in the position of making decisions about our sacred places while threatening to assume control over tribal preservation programs developed to reflect each tribal nation’s unique knowledge and lifeways." For Matt and many others, these are "not simply changes to a permitting process. They are deliberate attempts to undermine tribal self-determination."

Wesley Furlong, a senior staff attorney at the Native American Rights Fund (NARF) specializing in Section 106 reviews, underscores the current process as "one of the most powerful tools" tribes possess to inform federal decision-making. Annually, state and tribal staff conduct hundreds of thousands of Section 106 reviews, many of which conclude without requiring project modifications. Crucially, these reviews provide tribes an invaluable opportunity to educate federal agencies about how a proposed project could harm sacred sites and cultural landscapes, many of which are unknown to federal authorities. However, even under the current system, a review does not guarantee protection, and tribes cannot always expect a specific outcome. Furlong characterized the proposed bill’s Section 106 provisions as a "total dumpster fire and an absolute hatchet job" that clearly lacked input from individuals familiar with tribal concerns or the existing consultation process. He lamented that Native nations are being "forced to take the brunt of this ‘compromise.’ It’s permitting reform at the expense of Indian Country, tribal rights, and tribal resources."

The critical importance—and sometimes, the inadequacy—of Section 106 for tribal nations was starkly illustrated during the permitting process for the 550-mile-long SunZia Southwest Transmission Project. This massive undertaking aims to transport wind energy from New Mexico to California. In 2024, tribal nations initiated legal action over insufficient tribal consultation. The following year, courts sided with the tribes, compelling the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to re-do consultation for segments of the project. This legal victory allowed tribes to mitigate potential harm to cultural sites within Arizona’s San Pedro Valley, despite most of the transmission line already having been constructed. This case highlights both the power of current laws and the challenges in ensuring timely and meaningful consultation.

As currently drafted, tribal advocates express significant worry that the bill could also curtail federal agencies’ consideration of Indigenous knowledge. This could occur by altering the definitions of information agencies must consider under the Endangered Species Act, a critical statute for biodiversity protection. Additionally, the legislation shortens public comment timelines and restricts tribes’ ability to pursue NEPA violations through the courts, a vital avenue for accountability. It also lessens federal agencies’ mandate to incorporate as much relevant scientific information as possible in their decision-making. This could have immediate, tangible effects in regions like New Mexico; for example, the Forest Service might not be required to incorporate any new research published after it began its environmental impact statement for the Roca Honda Mine, potentially overlooking crucial, updated data.

New bill slashes tribes’ role in projects that impact ancestral sites, water and wildlife

Daniel Cordalis (Navajo Nation), a staff attorney at the Native American Rights Fund specializing in tribal water rights, points out that tribes frequently need to introduce their own data or information regarding project impacts after federal analysis has already commenced. Recalling his work on the Klamath River, Cordalis noted that tribal nations were compelled to challenge federal data governing water flow, which directly impacted salmon survival. Across the Western U.S., tribal communities often possess unparalleled expertise in fisheries science, forestry, and hydrology, and their scientific data may legitimately differ from the federal government’s. "Tribes often have the best scientists doing a lot of this work," Cordalis affirmed. However, rather than acknowledging this wealth of Indigenous knowledge and scientific research, the bill, according to Cordalis, includes "no recognition of the role of another sovereign government whose rights and resources may be at stake."

These proposed changes could lead to tribal nations being inadequately included or considered in large-scale federal projects. Furthermore, a provision within the legislation termed "project certainty" would make it significantly more difficult for the federal government to alter or revoke a permit once a mine, solar array, or wind project has received approval. This stands in stark contrast to recent precedents, such as the Biden administration’s 2021 action to halt the controversial Keystone XL pipeline, which had been permitted under the first Trump administration despite widespread objections from numerous Native nations. Similarly, the Trump administration had sought to stop Biden-era offshore wind projects, demonstrating the shifting sands of environmental policy and the power of executive action. The "project certainty" clause would effectively cement projects, potentially locking in harms despite future revelations or changes in administration.

As of early November, tribal leaders, environmental groups, archaeological organizations, and various community organizations were vigorously campaigning to amend the bill, urging citizens to contact their senators and voice their concerns before the critical Senate vote. In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for Senator Heinrich offered a contrasting perspective, asserting that the senator believes the bill as written does not harm tribal consultation. The spokesperson contended that the bill "defends against the Trump administration’s efforts to make all Tribal consultation discretionary and eliminate consultation altogether on cultural landscapes. All of this means stronger Tribal consultation protections, lower utility bills, more good-paying jobs, and a path toward unlocking our clean energy future." This perspective clashes sharply with the widespread alarm raised by indigenous advocates.

Cordalis concludes that tribal nations already operate with a limited number of legal tools to safeguard ancestral lands, culturally significant wildlife, and precious water resources. The proposed legislation, he warns, incrementally chips away at all of them. "The positive and the real good things that tribes have been able to protect over the years—probably wouldn’t be able to have been protected under this," he stated, highlighting the profound and irreversible losses that could result from the bill’s passage. The unfolding debate represents a critical juncture for environmental justice, tribal sovereignty, and the future of sustainable development in the United States, with global implications for how indigenous rights are respected in the face of escalating resource demands and climate action.